When securing passwords, it's essential to understand the distinct roles of hashing, salting, and encryption to implement the most effective protection mechanisms.
Hashing is a one-way function that transforms input data, like a password, into a fixed-length string of characters, which appears random. This process is irreversible, meaning the original input cannot be retrieved from the hashed output. Hashing is commonly used to store passwords securely; when a user logs in, the provided password is hashed, and the result is compared to the stored hash to verify authenticity.
Salting involves adding a unique, random value to each password before hashing. This ensures that even if two users have the same password, their hashes will differ due to the unique salts. Salting protects against attacks that utilize precomputed tables (rainbow tables) by making such tables impractically large and time-consuming to generate. The salt value is typically stored alongside the hashed password in the database.
Encryption, on the other hand, is a reversible process that encodes data so that it can be decrypted later using a specific key. While encryption is suitable for data that needs to be read or retrieved in its original form, it is not ideal for password storage. If encrypted password data is compromised, an attacker who obtains the decryption key can easily access the original passwords.
Encrypting a hash adds complexity but doesn't necessarily enhance security for password storage. The primary goal is to prevent attackers from retrieving the original passwords, which hashing (especially when combined with salting) effectively achieves. Introducing encryption requires key management and adds potential vulnerabilities associated with key exposure.
Use Case Example
Consider a scenario where a database of user passwords is compromised. If the passwords are:
-
Hashed only: Attackers can use precomputed tables to attempt to reverse the hashes, especially if common passwords are used.
-
Hashed with salt: Even if attackers know the hashing algorithm and have the hash outputs, the unique salts mean they cannot use precomputed tables effectively and would need to brute-force each password individually, significantly increasing the effort required.
-
Encrypted: If attackers obtain the encrypted passwords and the decryption key, they can decrypt all passwords easily.
In summary, salting a password before hashing it enhances security by ensuring unique hashes and protecting against precomputed attacks. Encrypting hashes introduces additional complexity and potential vulnerabilities without providing significant security benefits in this context. Therefore, the recommended approach for password storage is to use a combination of salting and hashing with a strong, cryptographic hash function.
