In the context of two-factor authentication (2FA), particularly with protocols like WebAuthn, an attestation object is a data structure generated by an authenticator (e.g., hardware security key) during the registration process with a relying party (e.g., a web service). This object contains information about the authenticator's provenance and the public key associated with the newly created credential.
Purpose of the Attestation Object
-
Authenticator Verification: The attestation object allows the relying party to verify that the authenticator is genuine and meets certain security standards. This verification helps in assessing the trustworthiness of the device being registered.
-
Credential Binding: It binds the generated public key to the authenticator, ensuring that future authentication attempts using this key are tied to the specific device.
Non-Repudiation in 2FA
Non-repudiation ensures that a user cannot deny their involvement in a particular action or transaction. In the context of 2FA with authenticators, achieving non-repudiation involves ensuring that any action requiring user consent (e.g., pressing a hardware key) can be incontrovertibly linked to the user.
Role of Attestation Objects in Non-Repudiation
While attestation objects are crucial for verifying the authenticity of an authenticator during the registration phase, they do not directly provide non-repudiation for individual user actions during authentication or transaction approval. The attestation process establishes trust in the authenticator itself but does not produce evidence that can be used to prove a specific user's action at a later time.
Limitations
-
Shared Responsibility: If an authenticator is used by multiple individuals, it becomes challenging to attribute a specific action to a particular user, thereby weakening non-repudiation.
-
Lack of Action-Specific Evidence: The attestation object does not capture or sign specific user actions; it only attests to the authenticator's characteristics during registration.
Common Usage and Standards
Attestation objects are defined in standards like the WebAuthn specification by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C). They are commonly used to establish the authenticity of authenticators during the initial registration with a relying party. However, for non-repudiation of specific actions, additional mechanisms, such as digital signatures tied to user-specific keys and proper user verification methods, are necessary.
