Please be patient with me; I'm still really new at this. In order to calculate the average of a set of values, I am trying to write a function. The group of numerals is actually a cog's teeth. Damage or stoppage is noted on teeth in a clockwise rotation, so damage at teeth 7 and 23 would be at 7 and 23 teeth from the starting tooth. The primary tooth is usually tooth 1 (identified as painted). When you calculate a normal average, there is an anomaly because the average stoppage at teeth 3, 4, and 33 would actually be 1, NOT 14.33 as per a regular average.I did the math to determine the average, and by average I mean a set of circular numbers that is closer to the median. I increase each value in the range by one and then use the MOD function to determine the difference between the highest and lowest values. It only takes a few steps to deduct the incremented number from the new average once I've determined the starting position of the shortest difference. Most likely, a table would describe it better.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8e3f3/8e3f398d50e9a2af8293c0915d67afa2a67b0958" alt="image"
As you can see, tooth 1, which is the average less the increment of the first group of numbers with the least difference, is the true average or median. The code I now use to run through and perform these calculations is returning a value# error, but I have very little expertise with custom functions and don't know where to begin to fix the problem. Any pointers would be greatly appreciated, and a solution would be excellent.
Public Function AVGDISTCALC(rng As Range)
'Determines the average distance of a number of distances on a 37 tooth wheel.
Dim x As Integer
Dim i As Integer
Dim avg As Integer
Dim diff As Integer
Dim Arr() As Variant
Dim r As Long
Dim c As Long
Application.ScreenUpdating = False
'Write the range to an array.
Arr = rng
'Cycle through each increment on the 37 tooth wheel.
diff = 38
For i = 1 To 37
Arr = rng
'For each increment calculate the min and max of the range.
For r = 1 To UBound(Arr, 1)
For c = 1 To UBound(Arr, 2)
If (Arr(r, c) + i) Mod 37 = 0 Then
Arr(r, c) = 37
Else
Arr(r, c) = (Arr(r, c) + i) Mod 37
End If
Next c
Next r
If WorksheetFunction.Max(Arr) - WorksheetFunction.Min(Arr) < diff Then
diff = WorksheetFunction.Max(Arr) - WorksheetFunction.Min(Arr)
avg = WorksheetFunction.Average(Arr)
x = i
End If
Next i
AVGDISTCALC = avg - x
End Function